Croft promised the environment of a diverse urban school, with the perks of a private institution for $35,000 a year — an affordable price, compared with other private schools. Families with financial need were offered steep discounts and aid at the for-profit school.
Teachers were beloved, offering not just rigorous instruction but robust social and emotional support.
All of that was ripped away on a Friday morning in mid-March, when an email from Croft’s board alerted Ullman and hundreds of other parents to the worst: Croft faced collapse. Within a few days, the board would accuse Scott Given, Croft’s now 46-year-old founder, of hiding $13 million in debt and fabricating financial records.
Get Globe Magazine
An engaging blend of award-winning narrative journalism, opinion, lifestyle, travel, recipes, and advice.
“It’s not just a school, it’s a community,” Ullman told the Globe a few days after receiving the email, fighting tears. “It’s an absolutely incredible place.”
The school had one name, but it was really separate campuses in three locations: Jamaica Plain, the South End, and Providence.
Families at all three campuses launched desperate quests to raise enough money to stay open through June. But saving The Croft School took each in a different direction. Providence’s campus followed its own course through Rhode Island’s court system before it closed earlier this year.
Parents in the South End took control, and created their own school, called the South End Village Academy, with many of the same students and teachers. On September 8, about 3 miles north of the Jamaica Plain campus, more than 80 students returned to the familiar building in the South End for their first day at the new elementary school, according to Ming Min Hui, the parent of a kindergartner and chairperson of the new school’s board.
Not so in Jamaica Plain. Croft’s Washington Street campus closed its doors in June, scattering its students into Boston’s public schools and other private institutions.
Watching the South End campus stay afloat, while Jamaica Plain shuttered, left some parents frustrated and angry.
“When the South End did that, and we didn’t have a school in JP, I was like, ‘What the [expletive]?’” one Jamaica Plain parent says. They asked to speak anonymously out of concern they’d face retaliation from other former Croft families. “I donated money for this, with the idea that we were going to continue.”
Months later, there are still some bitter feelings. Between campuses. Between parent groups. And all sides blame not just Given but the Croft board for putting them into the crisis. While law enforcement continues to investigate Given, families have accused the board of failing to properly oversee him and Croft’s finances.
For the board’s part, its members said in a statement that Given deceived them, and that they tried their best to sell Croft’s Boston campuses to another owner. But a sale was stymied by several factors, including the withdrawal of dozens of South End families from the school in early May, the board says.
The situation — beginning with the threat of Croft’s collapse, then weeks of late nights trying to raise money and create a future for the school — was too much for parents such as Ullman, who just wanted a good school for their child.
“It was The Hunger Games,” Ullman says. “Not a single parent or family asked or wanted to be in that situation that we were in.”
Croft School parents and students held a bake sale and protest on Congress Street in Boston in May 2026.Suzanne Kreiter/Globe Staff/Globe staff illustrationII.
Before its collapse, The Croft School had the makings of a feel-good story. Given founded it in 2018, naming it after the track coach and teacher who had motivated and influenced him as a student at Reading Memorial High School.
Given had gone on to graduate from Dartmouth College and Harvard Business School, then left a career in management consulting for public education. In 2010, he founded the nonprofit Unlocking Potential, now called the UP Education Network, which turned around failing schools in Lawrence and Boston. A few years later, though, the group’s disciplinary policies attracted controversy. Given resigned in 2016 after WBUR reported a Dorchester school being operated by his nonprofit issued nearly 70 suspensions to kindergartners, a figure greater than any other school in the state.
He wasn’t out of the education space for long. Given opened The Croft School’s first campus in 2018, in Providence. Jamaica Plain came next in 2020, and the South End in 2022. Given set up Croft as a for-profit entity; its finances would be private.
In the fall of 2025, Given pitched opening a campus in Cambridge as “another magical place to teach and learn,” according to an October 2025 social media post. But even as he proposed expansion, costs had soared, with pricey improvements Given had made to Croft’s campuses. Tuition didn’t cover Croft’s expenses, state securities regulators have said.
Scott Given opened The Croft School’s first campus in 2018, in Providence.Photo by John Tlumacki/Globe staff; Globe staff illustrationTo raise more money, Given asked for loans from families. And there were plenty of takers (more than $3.5 million from 46 families at Jamaica Plain, and nearly $3.2 million from 30 South End families, state security regulators would later report).
In January, in perhaps the first public sign of difficulty, Given told families in an e-mail that the Cambridge plans wouldn’t go forward. The other Croft schools were strong, he claimed. “We remain proud of the work we do each day and grateful for the trust you place in us,” Given wrote.
Two months later, on March 13, parents received that disturbing email from the board: It had placed Given on leave a week earlier. There were “serious irregularities” in Croft’s finances, the board said. “We intend to find out what happened.”
III.
What happened, state securities regulators alleged in June, was this: Given commingled his own money with the school’s funds, and used school money to pay for lavish family vacations. (In the spring, Given had denied using Croft funds for personal benefit.) And before Croft ended in financial ruin, Given began selling off his own equity interest in the school, according to a complaint from the Securities Division of Secretary of State William Galvin’s office.
Given has not responded to the allegations from Galvin’s office. He and the now-shuttered Croft school are also being investigated by the US attorney’s office, the US Securities and Exchange Commission, and Boston police.
Croft School founder Scott Givenuploaded to sourceWatch; licensed under cc by-nc-sa 4.0/Globe staff illustrationIn June, before the state securities complaint was filed, Given released an apology to Croft parents and the board through his attorneys. He confessed to borrowing money from family and the Croft Bonds program to help keep the school going, while hiding the school’s financial situation from others. Given said he did not take money out of the schools for personal luxury or enrichment.
“Words alone cannot repair what I harmed,” Given wrote in the apology. “But I am deeply sorry for the lies, for the betrayal of trust, and for the pain and instability my actions caused throughout this community.”
Given didn’t respond to a request for comment for this story.
Oxford Street Education LLC, which owns Croft, filed for bankruptcy earlier this year. Croft’s board, in a statement to the Globe, says its members were “among those deceived” by Given’s alleged misconduct. Given manipulated Croft’s finances, and concealed the school’s true financial condition, the statement says. The board says it attempted to save Croft, including bringing in a bankruptcy attorney, a restructuring officer, and an independent sales adviser, to help prepare the school for a sale.
But the sale never happened, and the board blames the lack of a buyer on factors including “financial uncertainty” surrounding the school, and a short time frame to broker a sale.
“Any suggestion that the board was unwilling to pursue viable acquisitions is false and inconsistent with the facts,” the statement says.
IV.
After the board announced Given had been placed on leave, Croft parents would have fewer than 60 days to save their schools: from when they learned of Given’s alleged mismanagement, to the day the board declared Croft’s campuses would close at the end of the 2025-2026 school year.
Both Boston campuses raised enough money in the spring to keep their buildings open to the end of the term. They hoped an outside buyer would come in to save Croft. But they began work to launch their own independent schools, in case a buyer never materialized. In either scenario, both schools would need the commitment of students, families, and staff to stick around.
JP had the tougher road. It was the larger campus, with 250 students in preschool through Grade 5. Parents would have to raise $3 million to start up a school, far more than the South End’s estimated costs of about $1 million. And the South End campus enrolled only 120 children in preschool to Grade 2.
Jamaica Plain’s rescue operation also had more moving parts than the South End’s.
The South End set up one nonprofit in the spring to collect money and help prepare for an independent school, should that become necessary.
Jamaica Plain families created a pair of nonprofits: one to collect money, and one to begin preparations for a separate school. A third body was formed to develop long-term plans for the campus — including talking to potential bidders.
Crucially, says South End parent Ben Howe, a lawyer with Foley Hoag, which provided pro bono work to the South End during the crisis, JP’s structure slowed down their progress. “In a situation where things need to move very quickly and the environment is very dynamic, I can see how that would have created a lot of friction,” Howe says.
The South End’s simplified structure helped parents respond more quickly, Howe says. About a week after Given was suspended by his board, Howe described a plan to fellow parents in Providence and Jamaica Plain to turn Croft campuses into independent, nonprofit schools.
“I know that there is a lot of exhaustion, but we feel really strongly that taking these steps now will give us a much better chance of at least having a path to keeping our communities alive in the very likely event that Croft fails rather than finds a savior,” Howe wrote in an email, a copy of which was viewed by the Globe.
The Croft School's Jamaica Plain campus. Illustration by Mark Harris for The Boston Globe/images: Securities document from the Securities Secretary of State’s office; Bankruptcy from US Bankruptcy Court in Boston; public records; protest by SUZANNE KREITER/GLOBE STAFFMatthew Donohue, a Croft JP parent, told Howe in the exchange that his group was focused on fund-raising to keep the doors open. To set up a nonprofit — amid uncertainty of Croft’s immediate future — would be too much, given the narrow time frame, he said.
“We are working to make sure the school survives long term, but short term operations are our immediate concern,” he told Howe.
Ultimately, it wasn’t until mid-April that Jamaica Plain organizers announced in an email to families and staff their efforts to buy Croft JP’s assets if no other buyer emerged.
Hui says as April progressed, with no sale in the offing, there were a number of late night calls. The South End continued encouraging Jamaica Plain to consider setting up its own school, she says.
“We were frustrated that they didn’t see our point of view and put in place the same structure,” Hui says. “But you know, we had to respect that they were making a different risk judgment call.”
Fifteen days after JP announced it was launching preparations to take over its campus, a major potential bidder — the UK-based Dukes Education — dropped out. Families at both campuses were notified by a restructuring officer hired by Croft’s board, and scores of families left Croft over the next few days, according to the board.
Donohue says the most viable option for the JP campus was a sale. But without a buyer, there wasn’t a way forward. After Dukes backed out, “I don’t think there was a scenario where a sufficient number of JP parents would have been willing to make hard commitments to maintain enrollment,” Donohue wrote in an e-mail to the Globe. “It risked foisting additional uncertainty on their kids. It would have been irresponsible.”
“I am extremely happy for them,” Donohue says. “But it wasn’t some feat of legal ingenuity that saved the school. It was access to the money needed to assume operations,” he says, referring to donor funds.
“They had a law firm that was throwing a ton of pro bono work their way, and they weren’t necessarily willing to extend that to our school,” says Kyle Raynor, who was part of a JP committee of parents focused on long-term options for that campus.
The aggressive tone of Howe, the lawyer with Foley Hoag, was a major source of friction between the two Boston parent groups, JP parents say.
Hui, who is also Boston Ballet’s outgoing executive director, acknowledges there was tension between Howe and some JP parents. But she and her SEVA board colleague David Schor defended Howe and credited his work with helping to save the South End school.
The Croft School’s South End campus in March.Jonathan Wiggs/Globe Staff/Globe staff illustration“Ben’s a tough lawyer, and that probably doesn’t work with everybody’s personality. It saved our school,” Schor says.
For Howe’s part, he says he was yelled at by a JP parent, Erik Hasenoehrl, during a conversation about setting up the groups’ non-profits.
“It was a stressful time for all of us,” Howe says.
Hasenoehrl denies yelling at Howe.
“Ben had some strong feelings, and I think I told him that I felt like we should move on,” Hasenoehrl says. “At no point did I yell at him.”
Suffice it to say, there was conflict.
V.
On the afternoon of Friday, May 8, Croft parents received news on their phones under the subject line “Update to Croft Community.” Basically, Croft was finished. There was the alleged fraud, the $13 million debt. A “mass unenrollment” of families. “We know how hard many of you worked to maintain The Croft School as you know it,” the email said.
Hours later, South End families demanded Croft honor a contractual agreement: that Croft allow the newly formed South End Village Academy to purchase Croft’s South End assets and take over its leases for the South End campus.
On the phones of Jamaica Plain parents, a WhatsApp group of about 100 parents had been buzzing with questions. They had seen the e-mail from South End parents, announcing they would be starting their own school.
An independent school to take over Croft South End’s campus? some asked. Why not us?
The Jamaica Plain Croft School on March 20.David L. Ryan/Globe Staff/Globe staff illustrationThe group chat of Croft parents was labeled, perhaps tellingly, “Torch-Wielding Mob.” And it got contentious, fast. Many didn’t seem to know that the South End was planning to form a school, or that they had shared their plans with Jamaica Plain leaders. Some argued over who — including Given, Croft’s board, the South End organizers, and the JP planning committee — should be the target of anger.
“Would be cool if we directed all of our anger towards Scott and the Board members,” one parent wrote, in a message others tagged with thumbs-up emojis and exclamation points.
Some were blaming the South End parents, claiming that they kept the launch of their nonprofit secret from Jamaica Plain, one parent said in the chat.
“Everyone [is] blaming SE and saying this is a snake move and it was done without JP knowledge,” the parent wrote, “which is misinformation.”
Raynor, with the JP long-term planning committee, understands why seeing a new South End school rise up to replace Croft leads to questions about why JP didn’t accomplish the same thing. “It’s just a different set of circumstances,” he says, “and I’m surprised that anybody would have thought that it was going to be near certainty that we were going to be able to save the school.”
VI.
At the site of the former Croft campus in Jamaica Plain, Alpha School has moved in. A branch of a national network of schools, the model uses AI tutors to help students learn fundamentals such as math and English for a few hours each day, leaving the rest of school time for group work and other activities. It employs classroom guides who don’t need teaching licenses, according to the company.
Alpha has the backing of powerful supporters including first lady Melania Trump and Education Secretary Linda McMahon, who has said Alpha is “the most exciting thing” in education.
Alpha boasts about its students’ test scores, but some students who struggle leave or are pushed out, The New York Times reported, citing their own review of Alpha documents, statements by executives, and interviews with parents. (An Alpha spokesperson contested this in an email to the Globe: “Alpha does not counsel students out based on academic performance.”)
“At Alpha Jamaica Plain, kids love school,” Alpha says on its website. “We’re not just preparing students for tests; we’re preparing them for limitless futures.”
Meanwhile, at South End Village Academy, some 85 children are enrolled from preschool to Grade 3. Tuition is about $34,000 a year, and the school says roughly 40 percent of their students receive financial aid.
Rebecca Ullman, whose son is at Dorchester’s Mather school, says the public school has been supportive after learning what families went through at Croft. Her second-grader is using the same curriculum he had at Croft, she says. There are a whole host of activities during the day, including art, music, and dance.
“He’s sitting in a little pod of kids.” Ullman says. “We are starting to get calls about play dates. They’re on the same soccer team. The connections are real.”
Due to a reporting error, a previous version of this story incorrectly identified when the Mather school offers art, music, and dance. It is during the school day.
John Hilliard can be reached at john.hilliard@globe.com or on Signal at john_hilliard.70. Follow him on Bluesky at iamjohnhilliard.bsky.social.

U.S. Supreme Court Building, Washington, DC. Photo by Jesse Collins, 2017, CC BY 3.0, cropped.